Unraid vs synology. With Synology, (I think?) this product, doesn't even exist.

Unraid vs synology 10. Sep 21, 2021 · Hatte erst überlegt qnap oder synology zu verwenden und diese im raid 1 laufen zu lassen plus eine externe zum sichern Als ich die Kosten der synology sah habe ich nach alternativen gesucht Dann bin ich auf unraid gestoßen und hab mich gefragt ob ich stattdessen die mediaststion hernehm die 8gb ram hat pico su (64bit müsste ich nochmal The exact same thing is true for Unraid. Jan 12, 2022 · Synology, QNAP, etc. I have tried windows, ubuntu, unraid 100 percent go unraid going forward stability, scalability . It is maddening and something I just need to sort, decide and move on. Synology +alles funktioniert out of the box - teurer (wenn man 4 und mehr bays haben möchte) - weniger leistungsreserve Unraid In my last post I mentioned I was looking for recommendations as I get ready to expand my Plex server (primarily for storage purposes). I love my unraid server for Plex, however if I had to do it all over again I would look into building a server that could run a xen hypervisor with unraid just as a storage os or something as unraid isn't the best OS for plex/sab suite. Sure if you have redundancy you can lose one disk (or even two if you have dual parity), that's the point and rebuild from what's left (the system can even stay up during the time). Compare hardware, ease of use, features, and performance of both systems. The first, and biggest difference between TrueNAS and Unraid is the file systems that they use. A lot of folks use Unraid and earlier on (don't know right now) there wasn't any support for 12th gen efficiency cores vs performance cores and plex hardware was iffy for brand new igpu. I have two unraid servers, one as an automated video server and the other for general applications inc. Unraid is for everything else. With over 20 years of history, a larger range of hardware solutions than Synology, and software that does pretty much everything Synology’s does, they have been consistent competitors. On the synology side I was looking at the 1823xs+ witn either IronWolf Pros or Exos drives (need to do research on what is quieter). One area that unraid is quite mighty though is it's community. However in my experience they do just work which is nice as i need this thing to not break midway and not break halfway. They are more or less using the exact same technology to pull this off. It primarily targets heavy data users who want complete control over their data, apps, and media. The Unraid community provides information and troubleshooting advice through its lively forum and easy-to-use website. Feb 20, 2021 · Das Backup Programm von Synology ist eh grütze, dem weine ich keine Träne nach. Also, find out how to back up your data to your NAS device with MiniTool ShadowMaker software. If I need an visual Studio, I can add a docker from the Apps section. I keep flip flopping between Synology, Unraid and my own spin of things. I've never been happier with my home server. If you are on a particularly tight budget, these are not insignificant numbers! Jul 6, 2022 · Synology vs. Oct 21, 2024 · Synology vs UniFi NAS – Hardware / Range / Value for Money. 3 I have been trying to install DSM 7. So I'm looking into building my first NAS/Plex media server. I ran out of space and wanted to move Plex/*area to the same box as the storage. unRAID and Synology are first and foremost store solutions. I don't want all 20 to spin up just to play 1 movie. I forget the type of RAID it runs, but basically if I Synology is typically very underspec'd for their price point, and upgrades like RAM or cache have very high markup. The hardware in the Synology systems is kinda crap. However with decent hardware it doesn't have any problem if you don't mind lack of things such as Netflix supprot. May 8, 2023 · Learn the differences and similarities between Unraid and Synology NAS devices, and how to choose the one that suits your needs. I mention Xpenology because if you’ve built and run a Hackintosh for years you’ll vibe with how Xpenology works and is maintained. I ended up moving over to Unraid after I was nearly about to purchase a 4-bay to replace my 2-bay synology. Unraid's innovative approach allows for better utilization of hardware resources, resulting in improved performance and scalability for your storage needs. You can buy a compact pre-built NAS from vendors such as Synology or QNAP while other operating systems such as TrueNAS CORE or OpenMediaVault will also allow you to build your system but function in vastly different ways to Unraid. TrueNAS is the normal option. A LOT of people don't like Unraid because of the data integrity challenges it has compared with other platforms. The other major difference is that Synology uses the Btrfs or Ext4 filesystem, while TrueNAS Jul 10, 2024 · Docker: i use syncthing to back up the appdata folder to another device so rebuild is decently simple // I my self have been using Synology for over 10 years. Unraid can assist you in quickly storing and protecting your data, running any program via an application server, and quickly creating virtual machines. net/pricing?via=nascomparesSynology/QNAP NAS vs UnRAID (ft. If you’re using for storage only, Synology is easier but unRaid will allow for easier storage pool expansion. TrueNAS to help you decide which NAS operating system is best for you. Apr 13, 2022 · Unraid is a Linux distribution meant to give you complete control over your hardware. Jun 18, 2024 · UnRAID manages to integrate numerous desirable features currently available in different NAS software in the market, but unifies them into this single software operating system. May 19, 2022 · Unraid vs fertiges Synology NAS Unraid vs fertiges Synology NAS. It's nothing like UnRAID. Synology - The easiest way to set up a reliable Plex server. Backend wäre dann wohl das Gnu/Linux dahinter. i have 2 8 bay synolology’s, I also have few 4-12bay rack qnap servers but all of those have slowly become secondary to my Unraid Servers which are 4-20BAY with mixed disks 12-16TB and Nov 25, 2024 · Since Unraid is a premium OS, you’ll need to purchase a license and activate it to use the operating system after the initial 30-day trial period. Everyone will have different opinions on this. Wenn du alles wie bei Synology haben willst, wirst du das wohl weiter nutzen müssen. For that reason alone, Proxmox is better in almost every way in terms of creating and running virtual machines. While Proxmox and Unraid can both run virtual machines, Proxmox is a hypervisor and Unraid is a NAS operating system. I started experimenting with the trial for Unraid and wasn't super thrilled. 3) for well over a decade. Using method 2, it should be ~200MB/s. Was du von Synology, als auch unraid siehst, ist alles Frontend. 5TB whilst have 2 parity disks as well as regular BTRFS scrubbing to ensure no silent loss of data due to bad sectors AND it Nov 25, 2021 · Ya, regarding method 1 vs 2. It boots from a USB thumb stick (and then ties its license to that stick). Have a new (to me) 16bay100TB SuperMicro dual Xeon E5-2695 v2, Quadro P4000, 198GB ECC Ram, 10Gb NIC server just waiting for a… 同时为了使用unraid的文件格式进行冗余，使用webdav协议把群晖里的内容实时在unraid所在的硬盘上进行备份。 当然，unraid的虚拟机也是支持其他系统的，例如常见的Windows，Linux等，于是又使用虚拟机建立了一个openwrt软路由，充当unraid系统的网关，充当透明代理。 I’m in the same situation. With UnRAID, for a 2 disk redundancy you would need to dedicate your 2 x 3TB to redundancy. Many of the lower to mid range off the shelf NAS solutions do in fact have ARM chips. 2 years ago I kicked a dual 2660v4 Xeon machine to the curb, moved to Unraid and a modern build. Dec 27, 2023 · In the ever-expanding realm of data storage and management solutions, the choice between Unraid and Synology stands as a crucial decision for individuals and businesses alike. It's about 9TB (spread out over 4 HDDs) + a 3TB parity drive. In theory method 2 is faster even with 2 copies, if we assume there is only few seconds gaps to change USB connection. Jun 5, 2021 · Compare three popular NAS solutions: Synology, Unraid, and TrueNAS. Let’s delve into the depths of these platforms to decipher which one might best suit your requirements. Synology's C2 Hybrid Cloud product also just works great out of the box and the HyperBackup product for servers and desktops is again worth like $1,000 a year. RAID for Synology Devices. If you’re comparing SHR vs. Is there a significant price difference? Otherwise synology all the way, or if u don’t need the ease of use synology provides, building your own is quite easy with spare parts. Ein Kumpel hat mir Unraid empfohlen, ich hätte dazu mal ein paar simple Fragen, da ich noch nicht so viel damit am Hut habe und das hier mein erster Beitrag ist. I mean an 8 bay NAS with minimal specs is 1k+. SpaceInvaderOne) https://youtu. File Systems. This is my vm config: STEP 1-Virtual machine creation: Download tiny Again, you're not wrong but I think there is a middle ground between "just buy a Synology" and "build everything from FreeBSD on CLI, GUIs are for the weak. SELL the synology box and recoup some costs. TrueNAS: Side-by-Side Comparison. TrueNAS! OpenMediaVault – What is the Best Synology NAS Alternative? OpenMediaVault is an open-source network-attached storage (NAS) operating system based on Debian Linux. But you can see there is a significant tax associated with it. UniFi’s UNAS Pro is positioned as an affordable 7-bay rackmount solution, with a focus on simplicity and integration into the broader UniFi ecosystem. Additionally since your Synology is mirrored it can read from both drives at the same time effectively doubling it's read performance, with Unraid you are limited to the performance of the drive you are reading from. Followers 0. You still have to have a understanding of what you're doing, certainly above the average computer user. I went from five 2tb drives to a few 8tb and 10tb parity. OpenMediaVault has all of the features you’d expect from a NAS This issue currently focuses me on Unraid, but the lack of proper backup solutions (snapshots) and some strange addons that seem to be necessary (like „fix common problems) don’t feel like a proper solution for the next, maybe 10 years. SHR is Synology's own RAID. May 19, 2022 · Hallo Leute, ich beschäftige mich gerade viel mit Datenspeicherung / Datensicherung. I was looking at Synology NAS' etc but they offer kinda rubbish hardware for the price and I'm not overly interested in their first party apps. It is known that Synology, as a NAS giant, has much in-built software to improve the products’ functionality. Whether to build my own NAS running Unraid or go with Synology 1621+ (1624+ when it’s released). The fact that people still consider qnap vs synology is astounding to me, I would’ve thought forums would be riddled with anti-qnap posts. So I got digging into unRAID and it seems a good option and allows me to build a cheaper/better DIY NAS. Feb 24, 2022 · SHR vs. Personally I schedule: SMART quick test on all drives once a day at 6am (all at the same time from the one schedule). Feb 6, 2023 · $ 179 saving vs the Synology DS923+ $ 172 saving vs the QNAP TS-464 $ 188 saving vs the Asustor Lockerstor 4 Gen 2 $ 114 saving versus the Terramaster F4-423. 5. In Unraid you assign this role manually. The downside is I would not be able to add the drives to a ZFS pool when I purchase them down the line. Proxmox is more powerful when it comes to more advanced vm features, like snapshots, clustering, etc. Jul 12, 2024 · Unraid also supports snapshots but for using the BTRFS file system. Running TrueNAS, Unraid, or Ubuntu Server from used enterprise hardware would be way cheaper and more powerful but not as convenient. OpenMediaVault has all of the features you’d expect from a NAS I think it was a youtube video or comment that was comparing truenas to synology where synology is something that you can sort of "leave and expect it to work" whereas truenas required you to be a bit more hands on and maintenance, but I guess this may be in the context of running several vms/dockers Since your Synology is only 2 drives I assume they are mirrored vs the parity situation on Unraid. I've gone through Windows, Linux, Unraid, TrueNAS, Ugreen, Synology, Qnap. Unraid seems to be a great option, with the ability to expand your pools later on. TrueNAS vs Synology: Community and Support. Oct 14, 2024 · QNAP vs Synology? As mentioned earlier, QNAP stands to be the most likely contender to fill this space. . Unraid: Ecosystem and Community Support There are solid communities for both Unraid and TrueNAS, with frequent forums and a wealth of online information. However, to that end, has anyone moved to Unraid from Synology and would you go b ack. RAID 5, as it’s the most comparable option. Which is not to say that many people are running unRAID on off the shelf NAS boxes. 1. For HA I had to buy a new RAM. be/xXmIQqFv Get yourself an UnRAID License HERE - https://unraid. By vGCaptainObvious May 19, 2022 in Deutsch. RAID, you’re generally comparing SHR vs. When it comes to performance and scalability, you'll find that Unraid offers a distinct advantage over Synology. I did a little research about to discover well recommended (and durable) flash drives and bought the Samsung FIT 128GB . Smaller form factor is about the only advantage Synology has, but micro-itx builds can get reasonably close. Synology - by Patrick Campanale; Join the conversation. No need to match up drives, you can put in any that you want as long as your parity drive(s) are the same size as your largest drive in the storage array (or larger). Synology has a strong community of users and many resources you can find across the Internet (forums, blogs, YouTube, etc). These are the key feature differences between Unraid vs. Do you want the mixed storage media advantages present in Synology DSM and Synology Hybrid RAID? No problem, UnRAID supports mixed drive deployment. Nur mal aus Interesse, weil ich früher mal selber Synology Get yourself an UnRAID License HERE - https://unraid. Jun 23, 2022 · Installing DSM 7. Aug 17, 2019 · I've been running an unRAID (currently version 6. If you have a good deal on a Synology box, just the Synology OS. It just allows you to make use of all available storage space of mismatched disk sizes, to an extent. Unraid – Virtual Machines. I like Photos a lot and another reason is to also de-risk my setup. That's why I went 10th gen. I started using HA was for about 2 years with a vm on synology. However the software side of things is where it gets a little murky for me. Usual stuff. TrueNAS: Key Feature Differences. Dec 7, 2022 · If you’re interested in comparing TrueNAS and Unraid, please check out our article on Unraid vs. Unraid will of course have a learning curve, no different than learning QTS on Qnap or DSM on Synology. It will I moved from Synology (8-bay) to an UnRaid server. And yeah, it is the way I love it. If you like the Synology OS but don't have the Synology Hardware, then run DIY hardware and Xpenology OS If you don't want Synology OS, but have the Synology Hardware, run DIY hardware with unraid. UNRAID is great, a cache drive helps immensely and I highly recommend getting a good SSD for that purpose. " I haven't used Unraid but I believe the license cost ($59-129) is significantly less than the cost of buying into the Synology ecosystem. I am pumped to learn UnRaid and to set it up (and try docker), but knowing myself I will swear endlessly if I have to put a lot of time in to keep it running. By Zelia / Updated on December 27, 2023. With Synology, (I think?) this product, doesn't even exist. The hardware is really expensive for what it is. Cá nhân tôi, Unraid là thứ tôi chọn sử dụng tại nhà cho giải pháp lưu trữ của mình. As others have said, different platforms and solutions have different strengths and weaknesses. Followers 2. Jul 5, 2020 · If you want them all in a single pool, then you need to go UnRAID or SHR (Synology Hybrid Raid). I'm also concerned about future expandability on both the Synology and the Truenas/Unraid route. Not sure if unRAID will play nicely with Proxmox - my understanding is it's normally booted from the USB device. Big problem was the overhead. I like how Synology is dummy proof I wouldn't call Synology dummy proof. 0. Apr 5, 2024 · TrueNAS vs. It's mostly great, except when it stops working and then it's a pain to figure out. Synology will on its own try to make the largest drive in your NAS the Parity drive. ftp support nfs support smb support, home grown drop box, download hunter. Synology SHR isn't like unraid, it is (not like, is) just lvm/mdadm. Dec 15, 2022 · Learn the differences between Unraid and Synology NAS devices, operating systems, and software. Those may all be worked out by now. It's why I went with unraid and mainly what I use unraid for. After hearing from some helpful folks about different options, I’ve decided I either want to build a custom PC running Unraid OR purchase a Synology NAS for both storage and to run my Plex server. QNAP, Synology, Western Digital, TerraMaster all offer both ARM and x86/x64 based NAS devices depending on price-point. TrueNAS was a little more work, install, import configuration, and then import pool. Also comes down to your ultimate goal. I have a rack mount synology for my Time Machine backups, I don’t know why I bought it tbh. audio. For my 20 disc array that saves me about 180-200watts. Trong khi Synology bán các hệ thống sẵn sàng sử dụng mà bạn chỉ cần mua, cắm vào và sử dụng, thì Unraid lại có cách tiếp cận hơi khác. Proxmox is a hypervisor. Depends your OS. 1 on my unraid server for the last night. Does it make sense to have a super basic Synology build just for holding data and then use my Intel NUC or other device with Unraid for hardware transcoding and running docker containers? Share May 4, 2023 · Among the popular choices for network-attached storage (NAS) systems, UnRAID, TrueNAS, and Synology have emerged as top contenders for peoples attention and their data! While each platform has its strengths and weaknesses, UnRAID stands out in terms of it’s flexibility, no nonsense use, and scalability. The primary differentiation is that Unraid has it's own closed source, proprietary parity algorithm and webUI vs OMV which is effectively just a webUI that lets you install software. so many apps can't - Buy a synology NAS, set it to SH2, filled with the drives & sell the old i7 computer- Set up FreeNas or unRAID on my old i7 full of the 12 drives According to Synology's website their SH2 protocol would retain around 18. I have tested both a failed Synology and TrueNAS deployment by putting drives into new hardware. The main difference between Synology and TrueNAS is that Synology is a device you’ll purchase that comes with the DSM operating system, while TrueNAS is a NAS OS that you can install on your own hardware. The hardware offered by both Synology and UniFi reflects their differing approaches to the NAS market. SHR allows you to use two-drives and when you do, it’s basically RAID 1, but most of the time, SHR is used for mixed-size drives in a RAID 5 like configuration. I tried synology TD over network, I think it's about 50-100MB/s. Unraid is more a energy saving optimized NAS with a little bit docker and vm support. Jan 12, 2022 · Hello, I'm looking to make the jump from a 4-bay Synology box over to unRAID and this thread made me smile so thank you! I've been using Synology for well over a decade and it you are correct, it's definitely made for folks who want something that they can setup and forget which has been nice but now that I have more free-time I would like to get into tinkering side of things because of the Mar 25, 2022 · Synology DSM 7 vs TrueNAS Core - Software Comparison Choosing between these two incredibly popular platforms for secure storage, accessing and sharing your data is not easy! With Synology and DSM, you have a premium hardware+software platform that easily emulates entire operating system levels of f Synology alone has Drive (which competes with $50,000/year enterprise applications) and officially supported Dropbox/OneDrive etc integration. 14 votes, 33 comments. Synology Assistant recognised the drives were from another device and just migrated them, reboot and it was working. Jul 17, 2021 · 3 yr peterg23 changed the title to Unraid vs. Here is my truncated view: Use Case/Thoughts. I run all apps in Unraid but continue to use Synology Photos. Synology is an easy out of the box solution with little to no fuss. . Their hardware also tends to be very proprietary. Most people here seem to prefer TrueNAS over Unraid; you could also consider Xpenology as a community supported version of Synology DSM. Reply to this topic; Start new topic; I love my unraid server for Plex, however if I had to do it all over again I would look into building a server that could run a xen hypervisor with unraid just as a storage os or something as unraid isn't the best OS for plex/sab suite. I can buy a refurbed corporate PC with a lot more muscle than a Synology for less than half the price ($150 vs $400 for a DS220+) but that isn't as "set and forget" as a Synology unit. With options ranging from NAS to DAS, Thunderbolt to SAS and connecting everything up so you can access all your lovely data at the touch of button can be a lot simpler than you think. It’s so boring and pedestrian, I had a synology box before that, and after the initial excitement of new tech, it gets really useless, fast. Synology is exclusively for photo backup and storage. Oct 26, 2023 · Unraid Vs Synology: Performance and Scalability. Jun 18, 2020 · Unraid isn’t the only option when it comes to building a network-attached storage system. Under the hood proxmox and unraid use the same technology, so performance should be same. TrueNAS vs. I took a look at Synology's products and felt it wasn't worth the price tag. Ease of use with web dashboard i taught pc novices how to use it or i hide from them and they just copy whatever to share on another family windows pcs. Lots of cold data, some of it important, some less so. Jan 28, 2023 · $ 179 saving vs the Synology DS923+ $ 172 saving vs the QNAP TS-464 $ 188 saving vs the Asustor Lockerstor 4 Gen 2 $ 114 saving versus the Terramaster F4-423. If you are on a particularly tight budget, these are not insignificant numbers! Jan 19, 2023 · This is actually incorrect. However, after good use and extension of the trial, I ended up going Pro for Unraid. You can post now and register later. After some problems and testing I have created this guide to install DSM 7. It just works and is very user friendly. Learn about their features, pros, cons, and how to choose the best one for your needs. Highly recommend dual parity drives if you can swing it - it makes commit writes to the Jan 8, 2024 · Aber da für mich mit der Zeit zu wenig Einschübe vorhanden waren hatte ich die wahl ob auf 4 bay Synology wechseln oder Selbstbau mit Unraid, da ich Lizenz vor Jahren Gekauft hatte für 6 Laufwerke habe ich gesagt Synology reicht zu teuer. Mal angenommen ich habe einen Unraid-Server bei mi Dec 5, 2023 · Ich werde nun trotzdem nach 3 Jahren zu Unraid wechseln, weil mir der Speicherplatz langsam knapp wird stand ich vor der Frage Unraid selber bauen? oder Upgrade auf Synology 4-Bay mit Erweiterungsmöglichkeit. I've been running Unraid for only a few months but have been impressed by parity and the adding of different drives. This issue currently focuses me on Unraid, but the lack of proper backup solutions (snapshots) and some strange addons that seem to be necessary (like „fix common problems) don’t feel like a proper solution for the next, maybe 10 years. net/pricing?via=nascomparesSpaceinvader One YouTUbe Channel - Spaceinvader OneThe Pros and Cons of UnRAI Jul 26, 2023 · Synology/QNAP NAS vs UnRAID (ft. When I changed to unraid I therefor try the docker Version. I love the docker version of it. Feb 14, 2021 · Hallo Zusammen, ich teste seit 17 Tagen das unRaid System gefällt mir wirklich sehr gut. A comparably priced unRAID build is going to run circles around it spec-wise, and be vastly more flexible overall. Unraid is just more clear about how this works than Synology which hides this action from the end user. Reply to this topic; Start new topic; Recommended Posts. I know TrueNAS and UnRAID are great pieces of software and I am also aware that, (As big of a pain in the neck that it is) Windows Storage Spaces also has a somewhat dedicated userbase. 1 on unraid working perfectly. If you want more CPU power, they take away plex decoding for some reason, if you want flexibile networking, they take away something else. QNAP is better but they def have their own problems. The unraid array is very space and energy efficient, energy efficiency scales very well as you add more disks, because only the disk with the files spins up. SHR works differently, in that it'd take your larger disks and split them up based on your smaller disks. I haven’t watch the video yet so I’ll probaby edit this comment but my top considerations were which one would have better idle power draw and have the capibility to backup some data to cloud based backup solutions. Might be able to use via pass through but can't recall anyone going this path. Oct 28, 2023 · Choosing the right data storage solution for your needs can be very intimidating and its never too late to ask for help. Unraid is imo, hands down the best home server OS on the market by a very large margin. Unraid vs TrueNAS in Software. While TrueNAS has ZFS and you don't have to have a USB as a critical part of your system. Mar 4, 2023 · Proxmox vs. Ich suche noch nach einer Lösung um im ersten Schritt ein Backup von meinem Synology auf das unRaid System erstellen zu können! Mar 25, 2024 · Unraid is unusual in that it doesn’t run of a system drive. Unraid is only as complicated as you make it. Usually, NAS devices will develop many excellent application services to enhance their product competitiveness, such as Synology. Sep 1, 2023 · UnRAID Installation on the Jonsbo N2 NAS Build Setup Walkthrough (Optional) If you’ve chosen UnRAID as your desired software for the Jonsbo N2 NAS, the following steps will help you get started: UnRAID on a Jonsbo N2 NAS – Step 1, Get the Latest Stable Release of UnRAID Nov 8, 2023 · Synology: more Apple-like approach of hardware/software integration and built-in apps that don’t require much technical expertise. -42661 on UNRAID 6. You will find few better, more helpful, devoted users anywhere on the entire internet. tend to be under-powered (especially on the low end) for the price and you can almost always build a more powerful unRAID server for the same price. SpaceInvaderOne) [NASCompares] By peterg23 July 26, 2023 in Lounge. QNAP - What I said about Synology applies except you need to also not give a shit about security. I've owned both Qnap and Synology as well as plethora of old relic enterprise equipment. Rarely happens. Nov 8, 2023 · Synology: more Apple-like approach of hardware/software integration and built-in apps that don’t require much technical expertise. Würde ich gerne Dauerhaft benutzen. Jun 25, 2022 · Unraid vs. eblyoos lpumlm ncz vjuiqn fcy fmi renbser rnzf awpupj agzvr